How these are built.
A skill is craftsman-class only where it reliably makes the model do the thing that does not survive being done from memory — the step the model, left alone, would forget, skip, fudge, or confabulate. The operational form of the same test: remove the feature and ask whether the output changes. If it does not, the feature is not craftsmanship. It is packaging.
Pass/fail. A skill that fails any gate is a prompt, not a product.
Gate 2 may be supplemented by a keyword list but is not satisfied by one. Gate 3 passes only if every claimed hard-fail is mechanically checked — one unenforced hard-fail fails the gate.
What the price is for.
What looks like craftsmanship and isn't.
One test covers all five. Does removing it change what the model does? If not, it is there to look like craftsmanship, which is the opposite of the thing being sold.
There are no testimonials here, no ratings, no customer count, and no founder to vouch for. This is a pseudonymous one-person studio and it intends to stay one.
What is offered instead is inspectable. The floor above is the same floor every skill sold here has to clear. The free audit tool measures your files against it and its source is public. The setup guides and worked examples are readable without a purchase. The changelog is dated. If that is not enough evidence to spend the price of a pack, then it is not enough — buy nothing until it is.
It does not ask a model what it thinks of your skill. It runs a script, applies the same seven tests every time, and returns an exit code you can put in a build. Two runs against the same file produce the same verdict, which is not a property a model's opinion has.
It does not produce a score. Scores compress a specific finding into a number that feels like progress, and a number is the wrong output for "gate 3 fails because line 40 declares a hard-fail that nothing checks".
It does not fix your file. It tells you which gate failed and what is missing. The edit is yours — an unattended rewrite of a skill file is the failure mode this catalog exists to argue against.